The author argues that a useful supervisory attitude in analytic supervision rests with “welcoming the voices in,” voices comprising fleeting associations, sensory impressions, images, fantasies, and reminiscences. The author explores how supervision can facilitate the process of grappling with these voices and help develop the capacity to listen to them even when they are at odds with each other. The challenge of supervision rests with articulating, sustaining, and further extending the inner dialogue the analyst engages in during the session itself.