You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
A pleasant and well written little book, in which the author discusses various psychological and social problems connected with the war. It is a book which a layman, unfamiliar with modern thought, would find interesting, valuable, and highly instructive. But it shows very little evidence of originality. The thoughts of the psychiatrist turn out to be, for the most part, thoughts he has borrowed from other people. They come from Freud, from Jones, from Trotter, from the behaviorists, from writers on sociology; almost nowhere in the book is there anything original or new. One need not, of necessity, reproach Dr. White for this. Not everybody can be original, and a good restatement of the thoughts of others is often worth while. But we feel Dr. White has gone beyond what is legitimate. Much of his borrowing was done, it seems to us, rather shamelessly, and with little inclination to give credit when it is due. Much of the discussion is in psycho-analytic terms; the point of view is largely psycho-analytic; and many of the ideas expressed are taken bodily from Freud. (Compare, for example, Chapter III with the first section of Freud's 'Reflections on War and Death'.) But Freud is not even mentioned in Dr. White's book (almost half of the references are to Dr. White's own writings). A reader having much familiarity with the literature of psycho-analysis and related fields is likely, therefore, to find Dr. White's book rather irritating, and to reflect that most of the thoughts it contains are best studied in the writings of those with whom they are original.