You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
Howard L. Kaye's Freud as a Social and Cultural Theorist: On Human Nature and the Civilizing Process is a historically and analytically rigorous redescription of Freud's works as, first and foremost, cultural and social theories. Kaye's reinterpretation displaces analyses by scholars like Frank Sulloway and Peter Gay, who describe Freud as essentially a medical scientist. Whereas Sulloway and Gay claim that Freud's cultural texts diverge from his primary calling as a scientist, Kaye wagers that Freud's works on aesthetics, religion, ethics and cultural change constitute the true foundations of his thought. Kaye writes, ‘It was [Freud's] work in science, medicine, and psychotherapy that was the “detour”’ (p. 163). This seemingly simple argument accrues complexity as Kaye narrates the fluctuations of Freud's stances on modern culture, religion and morality. In this vein, one of Kaye's principal goals is to illuminate the interweaving of cultural speculation throughout all of Freud's writings, beyond the segment of overtly social-theoretical works. In Kaye's view, Freud revolutionized our understandings of human nature, on the basis of wish and phantasy, and culture, based on an ethic of ‘restraint, modification, and compensation’ in response to a distressing reality (p. ix).
Choosing a chronological rather than thematic approach, Kaye's genre-bending monograph fuses biography, intellectual history and exegesis, offering an accessible entry to Freud's work while maintaining nuanced readings for more specialized audiences. Chapters 1-4 describe Freud as an inchoate social theorist before the publication of Totem and Taboo (Freud, 1912-13). In Kaye's analysis, the pre-Totem Freud offered frequently concealed and incomplete reflections on culture, insights ‘buried within his scientific-sounding language or limited to the occasional observation’ (p. 90). In his analysis of these pre-Totem works, Kaye meticulously documents the necessary biographical and intellectual items t