You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
This is the second book by Doctors Macalpine and Hunter and the second volume in the Psychiatric Monograph Series discussing a work by Freud. Some time ago when I reviewed here their first publication in this series, Schreber: Memoirs of My Nervous Illness, I
followed closely Freud's advice in his introductory remarks to the Schreber case. Accordingly, I used a 'policy of restraint', paying tribute to the authors' laudable efforts as translators and limiting myself to a few questioning observations on what appeared to be their rather generalizing and sweeping attempts at interpretation or reinterpretation. In reviewing their present effort it becomes increasingly difficult to maintain such a policy of restraint. To be sure, from a typographical viewpoint this volume is even more beautiful than the preceding one: format and illustrations are again superb; facsimiles and color-plates are of the highest order (the edition is limited to seven hundred fifty copies). Unfortunately, this is nearly all that can be said in its favor. Even the title is misleading. Only one-third of the text deals with what the authors term Schizophrenia 1677, and what Freud in 1923 presented in his paper, A Neurosis of Demoniacal Possession in the Seventeenth Century. The rest of the book is filled with the authors' ideas about mental health and illness, with their opinions about Freud, Schreber, paranoia, the case of Anna O, psychoanalytic training and technique, and various other themes, with manifold statements for, against, and about psychoanalysis, with variegated and numerous quotations from a great variety of ancient and modern sources—all of this (and more) offered with a good deal of repetitiousness and overelaboration. There are also subchapters on psychotherapy and psychiatric training (the latter should come about, if possible, 'without the exorbitant demands in time, money, and energy made by formal training analyses'), and even a chapter, The Classical Technique of