You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
Vamik D. Volkan's book is bound to be of interest to those analysts who are intrigued by problems of the emigrant-immigrant analyst who has passed from one cultural environment to another, and to those who seek ways by which psychoanalysis can make a contribution
to the understanding of history or of the evolution of social events in general.
Volkan suggests that the chief source of the bloody conflict between the Greeks and the Turks on the island of Cyprus is the fear of merging, of losing identity, and that underneath this fear lies a strong, regressive tendency toward a return to a symbiotic relationship with a clan's powerful mother. According to the author, the maternal figure is powerful among Greeks and Turks alike, despite the fact that externally these family clans are organized along strongly paternal, authoritarian lines. The persistent need for distancing oneself from such a central mother figure is met in major ways by defensive "splitting." (Kernberg's discussion of the borderline and narcissistic personality is Volkan's main guide in viewing ethnic matters in this way.) The existing "bipolarity" of Greeks and Turks lends itself to and is fostered for purposes of "externalization." By displacing the central conflict with the mother from the intrafamilial to the interethnic arena, the members of the groups achieve and maintain repression. The displacement is entirely ego-syntonic because from early on1 the Turkish mother, having been brought up in the same way, feeds prejudice against the Greek. She transmits to her baby the feeling that a visting Greek is a guest to be feared.
Because Greek and Turkish clans resemble each other so closely in structure and behavior, Volkan thinks they see each other as mutual mirror images (he must mean "unconsciously," although he does not make this explicit). Out of fear of merging, i.e., remerging with the externalized parts of the self, they must keep a distance from one another.
These arguments are introduc