You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
Published online: 1 July 2024
© The Author(s) under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Limited 2024
Julie Reshe's book, Negative Psychoanalysis for the Living Dead, stands out as an exceptional and unconventional work in the realm of psychoanalytic literature. It has swiftly become a subject of widespread discussion and interest, capturing the attention of many. This book diverges from traditional norms in several key aspects. It is explicitly stated as not being “recommended for anyone.” In her interviews, Reshe cautions that readers might regret engaging with its contents. However, the experience of reading it often proves to be the opposite—akin to finding a friend who is willing to listen patiently to one's deepest grief and darkest musings. The book's defining characteristic is its refusal to offer salvation or aspire to clarify or improve anything. Reshe posits that proposing salvation or improvement inherently involves a denial of life's darker aspects. The book appears to assume the role of a listener rather than that of a speaker, creating a space of understanding rather than providing guidance.
In her earlier work on depressive realism, Reshe highlights the stigma often associated with the voice of depression. Through her book, it seems she is destigmatizing this voice, offering it legitimacy and understanding. She admits that the exploration of human existence in her book centers around a fundamentally depressed being. She reconsiders depression and negative states not as deviations from our natural state, but as an intrinsic quality of human existence. Instead of treating them as distorted or inadequate perceptions of the world, Reshe views them as a form of attunement to our existence and the existence of the world. This book offers no consolation; rather, it posits that conventional forms of consolation, be they religious or therapeutic, often serve as mechanisms for denying crucial aspects of human existence.