You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
Several authors have argued that Freud's structural theory is outmoded. Peterfreund (1971) recommends an information-processing model more in keeping with contemporary cognitive science, which would facilitate the building of interdisciplinary bridges between psychoanalysis and allied disciplines. The proposal advanced in this paper agrees with Brenner (1994) in dropping the id, ego, and superego traditionally defined as sets of functions, but retains the terms ego and superego to refer to more narrowly defined concepts. The ego is useful when defined as a central executive, one that operates at the conscious level and another at the unconscious level. The superego is defined as a set of learned standards rather than as a psychic agency. The functions of monitoring contents pressing toward consciousness and the regulation of excessive levels of shame and guilt are more parsimoniously assigned to the unconscious ego. Brenner's replacement for the structural theory is criticized for its reliance on an excessively broad concept of compromise formation which blurs the content-mechanism distinction needed for an integration of psychoanalysis with cognitive psychology.