This paper began from the trial of Kyle Rittenhouse and my disturbing reaction to his testimony. In an attempt to understand my response, I examine both adultification bias, where black youth are seen as older than their age and more threatening than their white peers, and Whiteness from a psychoanalytic lens. Using psychoanalytic theory, social psychology, ethnography research, cultural examples, and my own self-reflections, I suggest a new term, White Infantilization, that describes how white youth are viewed as innocent and young far beyond when they should be and the costs associated with this. I use two case examples, featuring a black and white teen, where themes of adultification bias and White Infantilization are prominent, to explore the relevance of these ideas for current clinical practice.