You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
The author is Professor of Sociology at the Pennsylvania College for Women. She has had many years of experience in the field of criminology in positions of importance and has had many contacts with important people in governmental positions. This volume is called a “textbook, dealing primarily with adult offenders and their treatment.” The author, naturally and avowedly has written the volume from the sociological point of view. The materials used are “comprehensive”; the author felt, “that no textbook can hope to cover all the contributions hi the field.” In the field of criminology, long ignored but which society, in the last decade or two, finds itself unable to ignore, any such compendious book by a serious worker may be welcomed despite such glaring defects as lack of integration, misunderstanding of theories, omissions of important research, and even contradictions. Maybe the time is not yet ripe for a well integrated textbook—the field may be too newly sown. In these days of high costs, 874 pages for six dollars is not to be sneered at. The volume contains plenty to provoke students to think. The author does not seem to know very much about psychiatry or psychoanalysis. Some analysts may be pleased and some psychiatrists may be muled to find psychiatry and psychoanalysis equated. On page 334 an unpublished report is quoted with favor, belittling psychiatric reports as moralistic, yet on page 394, ‘immoral parents’ are glibly spoken of. Somehow Branham is quoted on page 183 in connection with the psychology of traitors, but the author is unacquainted with his great work on classification. The author is quite ladylike hi her condescension to psychiatry. The reviewer does not think the book will cause much harm and it will serve to get a lot of information (as well as some misinformation) around. The reviewer knows the tremendous labor that goes into a work such as this and it should be encouraged. Let us hope that if this textbook has another edition, it is pr