The idea of birth trauma places a psychophysical knot at the center of the constitution of the psyche tied to maternal space. What does it mean that the maternal is seen as a site of trauma and regressive desire? How do women experience being this place? While Freud’s neglect of the importance of the mother and hyper-emphasis on the father has been visited and re-visited, from the angle of birth trauma, an idea he fought against fearsomely, we begin to witness something important concerning his efforts to move away from this battleground. Not to erase the mother, but to leave something Real there intact. Revisiting three wild speculations on the psychoanalytic meaning of birth, I ask about this maternal knot.