You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
18 January 1933
81 Harley Street, London
Dear Professor,
I thank you for your friendliness in asking my opnion about Feigenbaum's latest proposal, and could only wish that some of our other Continental colleagues had shown the same sense of loyalty. You say you do not know what arrangement the QUARTERLY has come to with the JOURNAL. I know no more than you, for I sent you a copy of my final letter to Feigenbaum which completely defined the situation; if it is not accessible I enclose another copy of it.
My standpoint seems to me perfectly clear and simple. Feigenbaum admits that the QUARTERLY has no special function—such as concentrating American contributions, etc.—but that its aim is identical with that of the JOURNAL. This can only mean that in his opinion the JOURNAL does not adequately fulfil its purpose and needs to be supplemented. If I knew what the basis of this criticism is, I should be only too happy to co-operate with anyone who wished to remove the supposed defects, or else to be replaced by someone who could better fulfil the task. Instead of discussing this, however, Feigenbaum launched an enterprise which can only have one effect—that of increasing whatever defects there are in the JOURNAL. By his activity he restricts the number of contributions available to us, so that the level of what we publish must necessarily be lower than before, as there is not the same field from which to choose the best. And since few of his subscribers will also subscribe to the JOURNAL we are deprived of a certain number; we are so dependent on American sales that if the QUARTERLY succeeds the JOURNAL may well have to cease publication. In short, co-operation is replaced by competition.
You are the Herausgeber of the INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL and entrusted me as Editor with the task of supplying the English-speaking people in all parts of the world (from Japan to California) with the best contributions made by authors in every country in the world and in every language. That t