You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
Sonia was not yet three when she and her parents began their work with Dr. Sherkow, but already they were all feeling quite distraught and desperate for help, especially with bedtime struggles that drove the parents crazy. Sonia conveyed her concrete understanding of their complaint and her own parallel state of distress through her play. In one story she was perpetually “driven crazy” by a bus or taxi driver who frustrated her efforts to “get somewhere.” Dr. Sherkow got a strong taste of the crazy feeling when assigned the role of the driver commanded to go from one wrong destination to another, or of the baby who was “kept in a constant state of yearning.” Dr. Sherkow has organized her case presentation around the vicissitudes of Sonia's masturbation fantasies, although she likens this approach to looking solely at one artist's contributions to a whole school of painting and leaving aside those of others. One feels that she could not have written her chapter in any other way, as Sonia's compulsive masturbation at home and in her analytic sessions demands that one pay attention to its intrusion on all aspects of her functioning. Winnicott (1975), in his paper identifying the role of the depressive position in normal emotional development, comments to analysts who suggest that an infant may reach that achievement in the first half of the first year: “What a pity to spoil a valuable concept by making it difficult to believe in” (p. 263). In reading this case, I found myself wanting to say something along the same lines to Sonia: “What a pity to spoil a valuable pleasure by making it difficult to get relief from.” Freud (1905) considered masturbation to represent “the executive agency of the whole of infantile sexuality” (footnote, p. 189) and he recognized the organizing function it serves for development and the integration of body, mind, and object world. Sonia, however, turns too much to her body to rid herself of a tormenting sense of loss and yearning that is dr